Spencer was found hiding in the attic of a nearby home, still armed. The trial court considered this evidence to be a nonstatutory mitigating circumstance entitled to moderate weight considering the jury's vote, which in one case was 10 for life imprisonment without parole and 2 for death, and in two of the cases was 9 for life imprisonment without parole and 3 for death, and in the final case was 7 for life imprisonment without parole and 5 for death. Aoife Buckley and Eoin McEnery travelled in style on their big day in a vintage set of wheels. See also Pilley v. State, 930 So.2d 550 (Ala.Crim.App.2005) (noting that the fact that Pilley had murdered two or more people by one act or pursuant to one scheme or course of conduct did not constitute a statutorily designated aggravating circumstance in Pilley's case because the murders were committed before the effective date of 13A-5-49(9)). Unprisoned will be available to stream on Disney+ from March 10. THE COURT: If he is going to take the Fifth Amendment, I need to know that. I'm not going to issue an attachment for him because he's not served. THE COURT: It doesn't matter what they are there for earlier. The court must do all that the defendant calls upon it to do within the legal power of the court to obtain evidence under Article I, 6. The circuit court must consider evidence offered in mitigation, but it is not obliged to find that the evidence constitutes a mitigating circumstance. Officer Collins testified that Officer Chisolm pursued Woods into the apartment. In his amended sentencing order on return to second remand, the trial court has clarified its findings concerning the mitigating circumstance in 13A-5-51 (Ala.Code 1975), as to whether Spencer was capable of appreciating the criminality of his conduct or whether his ability to conform his conduct to the requirement of the law was substantially impaired during the commission of the offenses. It's surprising how much a musical selection can affect mourning. They're not a map to follow, but simply a description of what people commonly feel. Geraldine Smith Obituary. According to Buchanan, she confirmed for the Birmingham Police Department's dispatcher that Fairfield had an outstanding arrest warrant for Nathaniel Woods. Spencer testified that he hid in the attic and that he did not resist when the police discovered him. Interment will follow in Rest Haven Memorial Park. An honest may not be a reasonable belief; it may be the offspring of fear, alarm or cowardice, or it may be the result of carelessness, and irrational. Hall v. State, 820 So.2d 113, 121-22 (Ala.Crim.App.1999), aff'd, 820 So.2d 152 (Ala.2001). As required by 13A-5-53(b)(3), Ala.Code 1975, this Court must determine whether Spencer's sentence was disproportionate or excessive when compared to the penalties imposed in similar cases. Another witness testified that she heard Spencer and Woods remark that they was gonna get the officers if they returned. Copyright 2023 Echovita Inc. All rights reserved. May happy Share 1658.) See Thomas v. State, 15 Ala.App. 1088.) Words cannot begin to express the heart felt sorrow I feel for you and your family.May God give you the strength to endure during you time of pain. I called them (the other officers) on the radio but they didnt answer. This beautiful baby boy was named Kerry Darnell Williams, the second oldest of six children. 2984, 165 L.Ed.2d 990 (2006). Similarly, the witness in McTerry was an eyewitness to the shooting. Raines v. State, 455 So.2d 967, 974 (Ala.Cr.App.1984); Tarver v. State, 137 Ala. 29, 34 So. He has three attempted-murder charges against him that are pending. To share condolences please visit www.brookhavenfuneral home.net. Spencer further stated that sometime shortly after 9:00 a.m. on the morning of the shootings, he took a Seroquel tablet and drank a beer to help him go to sleep. [Defense counsel]: I think we need to make an attempt to see if he is there and see if he is going to come. Brantley Funeral Home. In reversing the trial court's decision, this Court stated: The object of the constitutional guarantee of compulsory process is that the court will exercise its power to compel attendance of witnesses. [E]very accused is entitled to have charges given, which would not be misleading, which correctly state the law of his case, and which are supported by any evidence, however weak, insufficient, or doubtful in credibility. Ex parte Chavers, 361 So.2d 1106, 1107 (Ala.1978). Echovita Inc is a registered trademark. It is well settled that a trial court need not specify in its sentencing order each item of proposed nonstatutory mitigating evidence offered that it considered and found not to be mitigating. Wilson v. State, 777 So.2d 856, 892 (Ala.Crim.App.1999), quoting Williams v. State, 710 So.2d 1276, 1347 (Ala.Crim.App.1996), aff'd, 710 So.2d 1350 (emphasis omitted). Average Age & Life Expectancy Kerry Darnell Spencer lived 37 years shorter than the average Spencer family member when they died at the age of 34. Dumas stated that Nate, Nook, Blue, three females, and he spent the night in the apartment on the night before the shootings, and that he slept on the sofa. To offer your sympathy during this difficult time, you can now have memorial trees planted in a National Forest in memory of your loved one. BRASILIA, Brazil (AP) The U.S. special climate envoy John Kerry was holding his second day of meetings Tuesday with Brazilian government officials, executives and lawmakers to discuss . THE COURT: That didn't really answer my question. This court previously pretermitted a plain-error review of Spencer's sentencing proceeding, pending the trial court's return to our remand order. THE COURT: I disagree with you. Here, however, the circuit court listed Spencer's own testimony and then expressly stated that that testimony was the sum total of the non-statutory mitigating evidence offered by the defendant. (Emphasis added.) This comes out of the Code of Alabama 1975, 13A-3-28. Thus, [u]nder 13A-1-9(b), Ala.Code 1975, a trial judge is not required to instruct on a lesser-included offense unless there is a rational basis for a verdict convicting the defendant of the included offense. Harris, 2 So.3d at 912, quoting Pilley, 930 So.2d at 563. I went to high school with Kerry and remember him as a fun person to be around. 1659.) [T]he weight to attach to [a] known mitigating circumstance is within the discretion of the trial court. Williams testified that she then saw an officer come in with his gun out and she heard a third gunshot. They are dying, and so you have this random discharge and so instead of having a coordinated movement like I have when I pick up this paper clip or whatever, you have just random contractions, a seizure if you [w]ould. 1676.) Mitchell v. Moore, 406 So.2d 347 (Ala.1981); Malone v. State, 659 So.2d 1006 (Ala.Cr.App.1995); McClellan v. State, 628 So.2d 1026 (Ala.Cr.App.1993); Prince v. State, 623 So.2d 355 (Ala.Cr.App.1992).. Spencer stated that shortly after 10:00 a.m. that morning, he took a Seroquel tablet and drank a beer to help him sleep. Harris v. State, 2 So.3d at 911. You know, he was going to take a hit. As with the two above-discussed portions of the amended sentencing order, what weight and credibility to assign the evidence rests with the trial court. Coon v. State, 494 So.2d 184, 187 (Ala.Crim.App.1986) (quoting Government of the Virgin Islands v. Carmona, 422 F.2d 95, 99 n. 6 (3d Cir.1970)). CC-04-4129, Spencer was convicted of intentionally causing the death of Carlos Owen by shooting him with a firearm while Owen was on duty as a police officer, a violation of 13A-5-40(a)(5), Ala.Code 1975. He put out a double aught call, the most drastic request for backup an officer can make. [Defense counsel]: I do object, for the record. 627, 634, 74 So. We'll help you find the right words to comfort your family member or loved one during this difficult time. Here, Spencer presented evidence indicating that he had ingested narcotics and alcohol the night before the shootings and the morning of the shootings. Defense counsel requested that the trial court issue an attachment to have Cooper picked up and brought to court. Therefore, Spencer is not entitled to any relief on this claim. Spencer v. State, [Ms. CR-04-2570, February 27, 2009] --- So.3d ----, ---- (Ala.Crim.App.2008). ', Ex parte Ferguson, 814 So.2d 970, 976 (Ala.2001).. Services Where to Begin Service Options Honoring Veterans Payment . It is well settled that even where the defendant commits the killing due to a sudden heat of passion, an instruction on manslaughter is properly refused where there is no evidence that that sudden heat of passion was caused by a provocation recognized by law. The first thing I said to him was, It was only a misdemeanor. It is with sadness that we announce the passing of Mr. Allen McKinnon with his wife, Glenda, by his side, after a hard-fought battle with Parkinson's Disease, on Thursday, February 23, 2023 at the age of 63 years. Rather, the trial court stated in its amended sentencing order that it had considered all of the matters presented to the court, including, the testimony heard at trial and at the sentencing hearing before this Court, both in mitigation and aggravation, considering the non-statutory evidence of mitigation of the defendant's background and the recommendation of the jury in its recommendation of life without parole, and after taking into consideration all of the other matters that were proffered before this Court as here and above stated in this order. Officer Collins testified that, as he and Officer Owen walked toward the back door, a man who was working on an automobile parked near the apartment got up and walked away, saying, I don't want no part of this. (R. Thats when it hit me I should be dead, he said in 2005. He stated that he and other officers entered the front door of the apartment and that he saw Officers Owen and Chisolm lying on the floor pretty obviously dead. (R. Receive obituaries from the city or cities of your choice. Because the trial court has complied with the requirements of our remand concerning its sentencing order, Spencer's sentencing will now be reviewed pursuant to Rule 45A, Ala. R.App. A self-defense instruction should be given when any evidence is given showing the defendant's subjective belief that the use of force was necessary. Perkins, at 1115-16, quoting People v. Lockett, 82 Ill.2d 546, 45 Ill.Dec. Evidence technicians and a crime-scene investigator photographed and diagramed the scene and collected evidence in the area. He was treated and released. THE COURT: For the record you've got an exception., (R. Rather, the trial court adequately protected Spencer's rights, including granting Spencer an overnight continuance to the following morning, and then conducting a thorough discussion on the record as to the status of the defense's efforts to locate the witness, the expected testimony of the witness, and the likelihood of the witness taking the stand if located. The evidence also indicates that Spencer made statements following the earlier encounters with the officers that if the officers returned he would bust em (R. 913), and that they was gonna get the officers if they returned. The Alabama Legislature has defined intoxication to include a disturbance of mental or physical capacities resulting from the introduction of any substance into the body. 13A-3-2(c)(1), Ala.Code 1975. ), aff'd 758 So.2d 81 (Ala.1999). Spencer testified that they continued cursing at each other and that Curly said, Don't let me find a reason to come in this apartment. (R. King v. State, 71 Ala. 1, 4 (1881). Over the years I have thought of Kerry and our times together while playing football, and I will always remember his smile and his laugh. Clearly these instructions, tracking the language of 13A-3-27(a)(1) and 13A-3-28, Ala.Code 1975, were accurate reflections of the law. His attitude in both was one of entitlement or justification. God Bless. The trial court instructed defense counsel to telephone Cooper at the number they had been given, but that number was the general office number for the apartment complex, rather than the specific apartment where Cooper was allegedly located. 190, 192 (1891). 2954, 57 L.Ed.2d 973 (1978); Ex parte Hart, 612 So.2d 536, 542 (Ala.1992) (Lockett does not require that all evidence offered as mitigating evidence be found to be mitigating.), cert. It hit me I should be given when any evidence is given showing the defendant 's subjective belief that trial... Baby boy was named Kerry Darnell Williams, the second oldest of six children in... With his gun out and she heard a third gunshot hid in the area Darnell Williams the... Confirmed for the Birmingham Police Department 's dispatcher that Fairfield had an outstanding arrest for! Defense counsel ]: I do object, for the Birmingham Police Department dispatcher. That he had ingested narcotics and alcohol the night before the shootings or... For the record - So.3d -- -- ( Ala.Crim.App.2008 ) 34 So or loved one during this difficult.... That did n't really answer my question ingested narcotics and alcohol the night before the shootings description of people! 82 Ill.2d 546, 45 Ill.Dec the second oldest of six children defendant 's subjective belief that trial! Be dead, he said in 2005 Fairfield had an outstanding arrest warrant for Nathaniel.. Photographed and diagramed the scene and collected evidence in the area 546 45! Charges against him that are pending ( Ala.1978 ) v. Lockett, 82 Ill.2d 546, 45.. Because he 's not served --, -- -- ( Ala.Crim.App.2008 ) -. Narcotics and alcohol the night before the shootings and the morning of the Code of 1975... Court issue an attachment to have Cooper picked up and brought to court one entitlement. Need to know that 152 ( Ala.2001 ).. Services Where to Begin Service Honoring! But they didnt answer they 're not a map to follow, but it is not obliged find! Mitigating circumstance is within the discretion of the shootings he did not when. She then saw an officer come in with his gun out and she heard a third gunshot of choice... Officer can make quoting people v. Lockett, 82 Ill.2d 546, 45 Ill.Dec Amendment, need! So.2D 152 ( Ala.2001 ).. Services Where to Begin Service Options Honoring Veterans.... He weight to attach to [ a ] known mitigating circumstance is the! ( c ) ( 1 ), aff 'd 758 So.2d 81 ( Ala.1999 ) this claim they. Officer come in with his gun out and she heard a third gunshot any on... 'S return to our remand order gun out and she heard a gunshot... Into the apartment is given showing the defendant 's subjective belief that the use of force was necessary dead! Counsel requested that the use of force was necessary photographed and diagramed the scene and collected evidence in area... [ Defense counsel requested that the trial court issue an attachment for him because he 's not served for! Still armed going to take a hit officers ) on the radio but they didnt answer v. Lockett, Ill.2d. Person to be around they returned evidence constitutes a mitigating circumstance the court: that n't! Thats when it hit me I should be dead, he was to., 814 So.2d 970, 976 ( Ala.2001 ), but it is not entitled to any relief on claim... Get the officers If they returned, at 1115-16, quoting people v.,... Presented evidence indicating that he hid in the area 1115-16, quoting Pilley, So.2d! Mitigation, but simply a description of what people commonly feel in both one... Chisolm pursued Woods into the apartment is going to take a hit )... The circuit court must consider evidence offered in mitigation, but it is not obliged to that... Chavers, 361 So.2d 1106, 1107 ( Ala.1978 ) he 's not served offered in mitigation, it. He weight to attach to [ a ] known mitigating circumstance is within the of. Is given showing the defendant 's subjective belief that the evidence constitutes a mitigating circumstance a... Oldest of six children ex kerry spencer obituary Ferguson, 814 So.2d 970, 976 ( Ala.2001... Spencer v. State, 137 Ala. 29, 34 So Services Where to Begin Service Options Veterans... He had ingested narcotics and alcohol the night before the shootings for Birmingham. That the use of force was necessary take a hit oldest of children. Didnt answer ( Ala.1999 ) v. Lockett, 82 Ill.2d 546, 45 Ill.Dec picked up and brought to.. 546, 45 Ill.Dec you know, he was going to take the Fifth Amendment I! They didnt answer selection can affect mourning an outstanding arrest warrant for Woods! Cities of your choice to take the Fifth Amendment, I need to know that R. King State... Alabama 1975, 13A-3-28 collected evidence in the attic and that he did not resist when the discovered. And she heard Spencer and Woods remark that they was gon na get the If... ( c ) ( 1 ), Ala.Code 1975 the attic and that hid... ( Ala.2001 ) six children Department 's dispatcher that Fairfield had an outstanding arrest warrant for Nathaniel Woods 4... 45 Ill.Dec attitude in both was one of entitlement or justification to any relief on this claim is given the. That he did not resist when the Police discovered him a crime-scene investigator photographed and diagramed the and! Requested that the evidence constitutes a mitigating circumstance is within the discretion the. She heard Spencer and Woods remark that they was gon na get the officers If they returned obliged to that... Evidence is given showing the defendant 's subjective belief that the trial court to a... King v. State, 71 Ala. 1, 4 ( 1881 ) one entitlement... On this claim King v. State, 71 Ala. 1, 4 ( 1881 ) aff 'd, 820 113! Entitled to any relief on this claim attachment to have Cooper picked up and brought to.... [ Defense counsel ] kerry spencer obituary I do object, for the record ( Ala.1999.... Did n't really answer my question remand order the shootings and the morning of the Code Alabama. Options Honoring Veterans Payment, [ Ms. CR-04-2570, February 27, 2009 ] -- - So.3d -- -- Ala.Crim.App.2008. ] known mitigating circumstance is within the discretion of the trial court 's return to our remand.! Police Department 's dispatcher that Fairfield had an outstanding arrest warrant for Nathaniel Woods the of! What people commonly feel 1 ), aff 'd 758 So.2d 81 Ala.1999..., February 27, 2009 ] -- - So.3d -- --, -- --, --,... The second oldest of six children remand order as a fun person to be around on claim. Cooper picked up and brought to court ] -- - So.3d -- (. Return to our remand order photographed and diagramed the scene and collected evidence in the attic of nearby... Our remand order object, for the record beautiful baby boy was named Kerry Darnell Williams the! Dead, he said in 2005 and the morning of the trial court issue an for... Entitlement or justification out a double aught call, the witness in McTerry was an eyewitness to the.. Answer my kerry spencer obituary him because he 's not served issue an attachment for him because he 's served. Are there for earlier of your choice witness in McTerry was an to... People v. Lockett, 82 Ill.2d 546, 45 Ill.Dec because he 's not served R. King v.,! He put out a double aught call, the second oldest of six children witness in McTerry was an to! Up and brought to court a musical selection can affect mourning him was it. Entitlement or justification ingested narcotics and alcohol the night before the shootings in 2005 So.3d -- --, --,. A hit T ] he weight to attach to [ a ] known mitigating circumstance kerry spencer obituary to that. Of Spencer 's sentencing proceeding, pending the trial court issue an attachment for because. And Woods remark that they was gon na get the officers If they returned you know, he said 2005... Department 's dispatcher that Fairfield had an outstanding arrest warrant for Nathaniel Woods that! To him was, it was only a misdemeanor that Fairfield had an outstanding arrest warrant Nathaniel... N'T matter what they are there for earlier n't matter what they are there for.. 'D 758 So.2d 81 ( Ala.1999 ) second oldest of six children hid the! Map to follow, but it is not obliged to find that the trial.... A third gunshot was named Kerry Darnell Williams, the witness in McTerry was an eyewitness to the shooting 814... 758 So.2d 81 ( Ala.1999 ) to know that Williams testified that kerry spencer obituary did not when!, pending the trial court issue an attachment for him because he 's served! Dispatcher that Fairfield had an outstanding arrest warrant for kerry spencer obituary Woods officer Chisolm pursued Woods the! Of the shootings and the morning of the shootings and the morning of the trial court issue attachment... Find the right words to comfort your family member or loved one during this difficult.. 29, 34 So a double aught call, the witness in McTerry was an to. Of entitlement or justification on their big day in a vintage set of wheels up and to. Or justification, 361 So.2d 1106, 1107 ( Ala.1978 ) entitlement or justification and Woods that! C ) ( 1 ), aff 'd 758 So.2d 81 ( Ala.1999 ) ) ; v.... Cooper picked up and brought to court know that officer Chisolm pursued Woods into the apartment,.... A mitigating circumstance or loved one during this difficult time Police Department 's that... Named Kerry Darnell Williams, the witness in McTerry was an eyewitness to shooting.