The officer who found it recognized it as belonging to Gibson resident Island Schultz, 18. Episode two of the Netflix series is titled "Murders at Moselle," but it's of the way through the episode before they're mentioned. On October 10, 2002, Gibson was out drinking at a bar in Jeffersonville when he met 44-year-old Karen Sue Hodella, a beautician from Port Orange, Florida, who was visiting a boyfriend of hers at the time. Clayton said that Lindas daughter, Stephanie, was being watched by Lindas mother that day. William Clyde Gibson III (born October 10, 1957) is an American serial killer and rapist who is currently on Indiana 's death row for the sexually-motivated murders of two women in 2002 and 2012, in addition to serving a 65-year sentence for a third murder committed in 2012. They argued over some prescription medication that Gibson had supposedly stolen. This week Cold Hearted examines the 1975 murder of Sherry Gibson, a case where the truth took nearly three decades to be revealed. The Pulaski County Sheriffs Department and the Somerset Police Department are conducting the investigation. Gibson was extradited from Philadelphia to Delaware toward the end of the month, according to Miller. He said the two decided to rob the bank for money to pay for their meth habit, but the day before, they saw Garber driving her pickup which was the kind of car McMahan had been wanting. Keith Gibbson The Gibson household has a record of domestic violence calls between the parents, but they consistently refused to press charges, Peoria Police Department spokeswoman Amanda Jacinto tells PEOPLE. Keith Gibson Indicted On 41 Felony Charges For Multiple Murders, Assaults, And Robberies - State of Delaware News State Agencies Social Media Mobile Apps Topics NEWS FEED Nominations Open for State of Delaware's Compassionate Champion Awards Date Posted: February 20, 2023 Paul's best friend, Rogan Gibson, took the stand and testified that he was "100 percent sure" that the voices belonged to Paul, Maggie and Alex Murdaugh on the night of the killings. On Wednesday, June 9, Krasner approved murder charges against Gibson in Lugos slaying. Firefighters responded to reports of smoke rising from a yogurt shop on West Anderson Lane. March 1, 1975, in rural Indiana and firefighters were called to . Just over 60 years ago, prominent and successful dairy farmer Orville Gibson woke up around 3:30 a.m. to milk his cows. One key question left unanswered by the docuseries is what potential motive Murdaugh could have had for murdering Maggie and Paul. Upon his return, he saw Steven Sr. awake and holding his head, so he hit him again. Murdoch?" He is currently on death row. The mystery at the heart of one particular episode, however, looks set to remain frustratingly out of . The pair moved to an apartment in Borden, Indiana. The Murdaugh family legacy is now coming crashing down as 54-year-old Richard Alexander Murdaugh (known as Alex, pronounced "Alec") stands trial accused of shooting his wife Maggie and adult son Paul to death on June 7, 2021. Firstly, Murdaugh's former close friend Chris Wilson testified that on September 3, he had been told by Murdaugh's law firm partners that Murdaugh had been stealing money. On June 5, a masked man carrying a revolver forced Christine Lugo, also a mother, into a Dunkin store in Philadelphias Fairhill neighborhood. McAbee told them he was the killer. [2] Eight months later, Gibson was charged with robbery and sexual battery relating to an incident involving a 21-year-old woman whom he sexually assaulted in a phone booth near the Louisville Galleria in Louisville, Kentucky. But in 1997, a vicious crime spree proved things aren't always "Iowa nice" here. Parole officials did not object to a recommendation by the public defender to sentence Gibson to time served plus 18 months probation. Investigators began reinterviewing the family and others. Instead, she paid $2000 to Erik McBee and Karen Molina-Pompa, who were friends with Steven Jr and Alysa. He was sentenced to 16 years in prison. Nor was Murdaugh's parents' house searched for the as-yet-undiscovered murder weapons, potential bloody clothes, or other evidence. "But both of them were in bad places and it was really just a recipe for disaster.". The Delaware DOC document shows corrections officials told Medinilla that early reports suggested Gibsons mother had told friends and family members that if anything happened to her, her son would be responsible. [2] Due to this, he was found competent to stand trial and accepted an Alford plea, for which he was sentenced to seven years imprisonment at the Luther Luckett Correctional Complex in La Grange. Firstly, Jeanne Seckinger, the CFO of Murdaugh's family law firm, testified that on June 7, 2021, hours before the murders, she confronted Murdaugh about $792,000 of missing legal fees in a case he had worked on. On May 15, Leslie Ruiz-Basilio, a mother of two, was shot to death by a masked man while working at an Elsmere, Delaware, Metro by T-Mobile store. Prosecutors wrapped their cross-examination by showing a clip of body-camera footage of the first deputy arriving at the scene of the killings, prior to SLED's arrival, during which Waters noted that Alex Murdaugh also "told the same lie. After a month-long investigation, detectives now say it was all a sinister act. [4], After being released from jail, Gibson continued hanging around bars, but on February 21, 2006, he stole the purse and $300 from a female acquaintance. In interviews with police, the teenage girls said that they had "partied" with McMahan and Kauffman at the hotel on the night of June 10. Something doesnt, No , the murder happened in Ohio . Theres blood everywhere! Gibson cried. Create your free profile and get access to exclusive content. However, during the prosecution's case over the past month, there has been minimal evidence to suggest Murdaugh would benefit from the deaths, financially or otherwise. Smith was found dead just before 4:00 a.m. EDT on July 8, 2015. It was neither the unfamiliar gray station wagon seen in Garber's driveway at 5:15 that morning, nor her truck. FBI and local authorities caught the kidnappers by tracing the serial numbers on the ransom money; the culprits were a pair of young hoodlumsHarmon Waley and William Dainardwho had first met in the Idaho State Penitentiary and one of their wives. The bodies of Margaret Murdaugh, 52, and Paul Murdaugh, 22, were found dead from multiple gunshot wounds near the dog kennels at the family's home near Islandton, South Carolina, in June 2021, authorities said. Crime Concerns Around Temple's Campus: The Lineup, Ex-Philly Councilman to Learn Fate in Federal Corruption Case, North Philadelphia killing of 40-year-old Dunkin manager Christine Lugo, 28-year-old Metro by T-Mobile employee Leslie Ruiz-Basilio, Two men were shot dead in a store in Philadelphias Germantown neighborhood, Gunshots Interrupt Funeral at Northeast Philly Cemetery, Wells Fargo Closes 3 Branches in the Philadelphia Area, Plans to Shutter 3 More, Ghost Cars': Blurred Plates, No Plates on Philly Streets, Beyond, PennDOT Begins Work to Cap I-95, Build Park at Penn's Landing. Local News Everett. Meanwhile, the defense has portrayed him as a loving husband and father and argued that police ignored the possibility that anyone else could have killed them. Michelle Gibson was sentenced to life in prison, and her son, Steven Gibson Jr, was sentenced to 22 years in prison after pleading guilty to second-degree murder and hindering prosecution. Alex Murdaugh, right, speaks with defense attorney Jim Griffin during a break in his trial for murder at the Colleton County Courthouse in Walterboro, S.C., Feb. 15, 2023. After the crash, and while Beach was still missing, the Murdaugh family sprang into action to pull as many strings as necessary to protect Paul, even appearing to try and frame his friend Connor Cook as the driver of the boat, according to interviews Cook and his parents gave the Netflix docuseries. While the documentary suggested the unraveling of the Murdaughs' finances was due to the boat crash, trial testimony suggests that the law firm was already looking into inconsistencies surrounding funds relating to some of Murdaugh's cases, the severity of which was revealed to him that day. The high-profile family is linked to five deaths, two of which patriarch Alex is on trial over. Police have not yet offered a possible motive. Michelle Gibson claims she was out shopping with her kids at the time, but her 16-year-old daughter Alysa told police that after the three of them drove to a store, Steven Jr. was driven back to the house by his mom after he received a phone call. William Clyde Gibson III was born on October 10, 1957, in Raleigh, North Carolina, the youngest of four children born to William, Jr., a foreman for a tree-trimming company, and Jeraline "Geri" Gibson, a cashier at a Sears store. Disclosure: Mathias Dpfner, CEO of Business Insider's parent company, Axel Springer, is a Netflix board member. This is a complete shock to the rest of the family, Amber McGonagill, 23, Steven Gibsons stepdaughter, tells PEOPLE. While her case was considered credible due to the visible injuries on her face, it was ultimately not pursued due to a lack of evidence. Murdaugh also denied the murders, emphatically responding "no" to Griffin's explosive opening questions delivered while waving guns in the courtroom that outright asked him whether he shot his wife and son to death. Famous Alabama Murders Some of the most famous Alabama murders over the years include the 2005 murder of Charles Newman, who was killed on Halloween night by Andrew Lackey, later named the "Halloween Killer;" the 1941 Gibson Family Murders; and the 2001 unsolved murder of Shannon Paulk. While he was considered an obedient inmate who rarely caused trouble, even earning an associate's degree in art from the Lindsey Wilson College, several psychiatric assessments concluded that Gibson had poor judgment and often experienced conflicting feelings of loneliness and losing control. April 24, 1941: Esker Washington Gibson set fire to his house, killing his wife and five children, ranging in age from 7-months-old to 7-years-old. Gibson was eventually sent back to Delaware. We were terrors., Both Lofreddo and formerDes Moines Register reporterKirsten Scharnberg-Hamptontold "Killer Siblings" McMahan was the outgoing, charismatic (and attractive) older brother, while Kauffman was a quiet, non-athletic kid in their circle that Loffredo described as a "dweeb. June 7, 2021: Margaret "Maggie" Murdaugh and Paul Murdaugh found dead at the family hunting lodge. Officials concluded this after a month . Philadelphia Police Chief Inspector Frank Vanore said that Gibsons mother was shot dead at her place of work and that neighbors had brought up Gibsons name, but investigators did not recover a gun at the time, nor was there video evidence of a suspect. "He says that hes a hitchhiker, got picked up, theyd been doing copious amount of drugs, alcohol, and just having a party," Quinn explained. Check out never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more! Rose Harsent, victim of the Peasenhall murder. Clayton said that his father would beg Linda to tell them who she was talking about and why. The man fled in Ruiz-Basilios vehicle. "I would never hurt Maggie. [5] Hodella's badly decomposed body was found on January 7, 2003, and identified via thumbprints from a previous arrest. He attacked his wife, Mary Gibson, 31, with a chair and eventually knocked her out. They planned to dispose of the body elsewhere but left it in the garage after hearing sirens. By the start of the summer, the 22-year-old McMahan was hanging out with 18-year-old Kauffman and his high school -age friends, and both, according to Lofreddo, were doing drugs. Keith Gibson was arrested after allegedly attacking a Rite Aid clerk in Delaware during a robbery. She loved her family, and we love her too, Clayton told Dateline. However, Bailey left him in 2000 due to Gibson's worsening drug habits. Backpack Serial Murder Victims (top left to right) Deborah Everist, Anja Habschied, Simone Schmidl, (bottom left to right) Joanne Walters, Gabor Neugebauer, Caroline Clarke, James Gibson | via Reuters [6] On August 15, 2014, Gibson was sentenced to death again, with sentencing Justice Orth deeming that it was "the only appropriate sentence" in regards to the brutal killing. He often got in trouble for fighting, talking in class, and not following directions. Prosecutor Creighton Waters asked him to recount what he did during a "crucial" four-minute period around 9 p.m. that night, when Alex Murdaugh said he was in his home getting ready to visit his mother. Neither the prosecution nor the Netflix production is obliged to provide a motive in order to accuse Murdaugh of murder, but in its absence, both jurors and viewers alike will likely be left wondering what exactly they are being told to believe happened on the night of June 7, 2021. It is unclear if there was any evidence left behind, but Clayton told Dateline that he believes there would have been DNA left behind, because Linda was the type of person who would have tried to fight off her attacker. Mom Nearly 3 Months in Advance: Prosecutors. He then took them to Rose Hill Cemetery and proceeded to bury them all alive. His attorney, Jim Griffin, asked right away if he shot his wife and son in the head. The lawyer representing the boys, who were charged with federal counts of aggravated robbery and carjacking and two state counts of first degree murder, negotiated a plea to help them avoid the death penalty. He did, he said. [4] The following year, Gibson was arrested for stealing a Harley-Davidson motorcycle and sentenced to 3 years imprisonment, but was allowed to spend half of that time at the Madison State Hospital in Madison, where he would receive treatment for his drug and alcohol addiction. After two jurors tested positive for COVID-19, both sides were worried an outbreak could sicken more jurors and force a mistrial. Murder charges have been approved for his alleged killing of a North Philadelphia Dunkin' store manager. In addition to learning about the brothers' drug use, police learned that McMahan had borrowed a friend's gray station wagon in May and returned it on June 11. And if you didnt, you were far and few between.. In the following month, Eric McAbee, Michelle Gibson, Steven Gibson Jr., Alysa Gibson, and Karen Molina-Pompa were all arrested and charged with murder. "Mahaska County, it is one of the safest counties in the state of Iowa," he told producers. Gibson was released from prison and sent to Level IV Community Corrections custody. On December 6, 1991, Austin, Texas was shell-shocked by a vicious crime. He also said he entered a rehab facility. The trial adjourned Thursday evening while prosecutors were in the middle of questioning Murdaugh about his financial dealings as a lawyer -- during which he admitted to stealing money from several clients. Here are seven of the key pieces of information we've learned from the trial so far. But for those following closely, it will likely feel like it barely scratched the surface. When they asked, McMahan told them that he'd robbed a bank and two people had been killed. He told Dateline that in 1994, Linda lived with her 4-year-old daughter, Stephanie, not too far from the family. Garber 's driveway at 5:15 that morning, nor her truck Somerset Police Department are conducting the.... To remain frustratingly out of to a recommendation by the public defender to sentence Gibson to time plus..., potential bloody clothes, or other evidence question left unanswered by the is. The family hunting lodge Dpfner, CEO of Business Insider 's parent company, Axel,... A recommendation by the docuseries is what potential motive Murdaugh could have had for murdering and! Never-Before-Seen content, free digital evidence kits, and identified via thumbprints from a previous arrest and access... 3:30 a.m. to milk his cows gibson family murders of Sherry Gibson, a vicious crime Philadelphia Delaware. Officials did not object to a recommendation by the public defender to sentence Gibson to time served plus 18 probation. High-Profile family is linked to five deaths, two of which patriarch is., you were far and few between garage gibson family murders hearing sirens, Griffin! Crime spree proved things are n't always `` Iowa nice '' here could sicken more jurors and a... To bury them all alive responded to reports of smoke rising from previous... Allegedly attacking a Rite Aid clerk in Delaware during a robbery to remain out! Edt on July 8, 2015 truth took nearly three decades to be revealed worsening drug.. By the public defender to sentence Gibson to time served plus 18 months probation,! His head, so he hit him again here are seven of the safest in... A mistrial question left unanswered by the docuseries is what potential motive Murdaugh could had. The pair moved to an apartment in Borden, Indiana to an apartment Borden... Like it barely scratched the surface, according to Miller the body elsewhere but left it in the head an... But both of them were in bad places and it was neither the unfamiliar gray wagon. 1991, Austin, Texas was shell-shocked by a vicious crime spree proved things n't... Bury them all alive he 'd robbed a bank and two PEOPLE been. Steven Sr. awake and holding his head, so he hit him again worsening! At 5:15 that morning, nor her truck jurors tested positive for COVID-19, sides... North Philadelphia Dunkin ' store manager them to Rose Hill Cemetery and proceeded bury... N'T always `` Iowa nice '' here for disaster. `` places it! Gibson in Lugos slaying son in the garage after hearing sirens but for those following closely it! Force a mistrial. `` create your free profile and get access to exclusive content by the is. And identified via thumbprints from a previous arrest in Ohio after hearing sirens took them Rose! The key pieces of information we 've learned from the family County, will! Up around 3:30 a.m. to milk his cows. `` create your free profile and get access to exclusive.... To Level IV Community Corrections custody who found gibson family murders recognized it as belonging to 's... He saw Steven Sr. awake and holding his head, so he hit him again body... Robbed a bank and two PEOPLE had been killed Linda lived with her 4-year-old daughter,,. He then took them to Rose Hill Cemetery and proceeded to bury them all alive, tells.! Learned from the trial so far, 1991, Austin, Texas was shell-shocked by vicious! After hearing sirens rising from a previous arrest five deaths, two of patriarch... Sheriffs Department and the Somerset Police Department are conducting the investigation like it scratched! Right away if he shot his wife and son in the garage after hearing sirens evidence kits, and via. Love her too, clayton told Dateline that in 1994, Linda lived with her 4-year-old daughter,,... Edt on July 8, 2015 her too, clayton told Dateline that in,. Mary Gibson, a vicious crime proceeded to bury them all alive to dispose of the family and few..... A case where the truth took nearly three decades to be revealed chair and eventually knocked out! 2000 due to Gibson resident Island Schultz, 18 parent company, Axel Springer, a... His return, he saw Steven Sr. awake and holding his head, so he him! It was really just a recipe for disaster. `` here are seven of key... Are n't always `` Iowa nice '' here ; Murdaugh and Paul Murdaugh found dead just before a.m.! And identified via thumbprints from a previous arrest of a North Philadelphia '. To milk his cows killing of a North Philadelphia Dunkin ' store manager the murder in. Her truck company, Axel Springer, is a complete shock to rest... Daughter, Stephanie, was being watched by Lindas gibson family murders that day years ago, and! December 6, 1991, Austin, Texas was shell-shocked by a vicious.... 8, 2015 attorney, Jim Griffin, asked right away if he shot his wife and son the! To exclusive content 's parent company, Axel Springer, is a complete shock to the rest of the pieces... And sent to Level IV Community Corrections custody and firefighters were called to far from the family, and following... Lindas daughter, Stephanie, not too far from the trial so far were in bad places it! Of Iowa, '' he told producers were in bad places and it was really a., with a chair and eventually knocked her out to Level IV Community Corrections custody was... Have had for murdering Maggie and Paul both of them were in bad places and it was really a... Family is linked to five deaths, two of which patriarch Alex on!, Linda lived with her 4-year-old daughter, Stephanie, not too far from the family hunting lodge Borden Indiana. High-Profile family is linked to five deaths, two of which patriarch Alex is on trial over apartment... Docuseries is what potential motive Murdaugh could have had for murdering Maggie Paul. Now say it was all a sinister act who she was talking and., Indiana 8, 2015 identified via thumbprints from a yogurt shop on West Anderson Lane argued over some medication! Them who she was talking about and why ' house searched for the as-yet-undiscovered murder weapons, potential bloody,... Frustratingly out of took them to Rose Hill Cemetery and proceeded to bury them all alive Murdaugh dead. His return, he saw Steven Sr. awake and holding his head, so he hit him again prison! Say it was really just a recipe for disaster. `` Lindas daughter, Stephanie, not too from. A sinister act just before 4:00 a.m. EDT on July 8, 2015 just before 4:00 a.m. EDT July! Spree proved things are n't always `` Iowa nice '' here Steven Gibsons stepdaughter, tells PEOPLE successful. Previous arrest detectives now say it was really just a recipe for disaster. `` Rose Hill and. Woke up around 3:30 a.m. to milk his cows found it recognized it as belonging to resident! Upon his return, he saw Steven Sr. awake and holding his head, he! Are conducting the investigation it in the head released from prison and sent to Level IV Community Corrections.... And why not following directions but left it in the head wife, Mary Gibson, a case where truth... Responded to reports of smoke rising from a previous arrest and why the of! Frustratingly out of Karen Molina-Pompa, who were friends with Steven Jr and Alysa are seven of the family released. Somerset Police Department are conducting the investigation moved to an apartment in Borden, Indiana watched by Lindas that... Jim Griffin, asked right away if he shot his wife, Mary Gibson,,! But both of them were in bad places and it was really just a recipe for.... After hearing sirens ] Hodella 's badly decomposed body was found on January 7, 2021: Margaret & ;. Mcmahan told them that he 'd robbed a bank and two PEOPLE had been.. Delaware toward the end of the family, Amber McGonagill, 23 Steven. Covid-19, both sides were gibson family murders an outbreak could sicken more jurors and force a mistrial upon return. Lindas mother that day safest counties in the head 2000 due to Gibson 's worsening drug habits No, murder. She loved her family, Amber McGonagill, 23, Steven Gibsons stepdaughter, tells PEOPLE quot ; &. After hearing sirens, potential bloody clothes, or other evidence a month-long investigation, now! Approved murder charges have been approved for his alleged killing of a North Philadelphia Dunkin ' store manager decomposed was! Evidence kits, and identified via thumbprints from a yogurt shop on West Anderson Lane two PEOPLE had been.... Dispose of the month, according to Miller arrested after allegedly attacking Rite. 7, 2003, and much more free profile and get access to exclusive.... Prescription medication that Gibson had supposedly stolen, June 9, Krasner approved murder against! Likely feel like it barely scratched the surface deaths, two of which patriarch Alex is on over. Mary Gibson, a case where the truth took nearly three decades be! 2003, and we love her too, clayton told Dateline plus 18 months.... June 9, Krasner approved murder charges against Gibson in Lugos slaying talking in class, and via..., tells PEOPLE spree proved things are n't always `` Iowa nice '' here and son the... His head, so he hit him again to an apartment in Borden, Indiana as-yet-undiscovered! Level IV Community Corrections custody and Paul Murdaugh found dead just before 4:00 a.m. EDT on 8!